Have you dreamed of having a perfectly reheated slice of pizza? The kind where your crust is still crispy, the cheese pulls apart just like the night before, and the toppings taste just as fresh. MMmmmmmm yum! Ok but how can you ensure that your pizza tastes almost as delicious as it does on day 1? Well lucky for you, Empire Slice House has researched the best ways to reheat pizza and have created this blog on your behalf. Stick around to find out the best way to reheat pizza and other tips like how long to reheat a slice of pizza in the oven. Also, make sure to follow us on social media to stay up to date on all things Empire including our holiday hours, special deals, and pies of the month!


Top 3 Best Ways To Reheat Pizza

Pizza is a special kind of food because it’s good when it’s straight out of the fridge (hello cold pizza for breakfast!), yet it’s also good when it’s reheated. But what is the best way to reheat pizza to its original mouthwatering glory? Below we have organized our research of the best ways to reheat pizza in an oven, a microwave, and in an air fryer. We want to know which method you think is the best!


Reheat Pizza In Oven

Time: 25-35 minutes

Temp: 275ºF

Rating: 8/10


Reheating pizza in an oven although takes a little longer than the other 2 reheating methods we discuss, it is well worth the trouble. To reheat pizza in an oven, you’ll need a couple more things than just the pizza and the oven. This method also calls for aluminum foil, and a rimmed baking sheet.

How to reheat pizza in an oven is the way that’s most recommended, but it takes the longest. You might be wondering how long to reheat a slice of pizza in the oven. What’s that saying, good things come to those who wait? All you have to do is place your leftover slices of pizza on a rimmed baking sheet and cover tightly with aluminum foil. Make sure you put the baking sheet on the lowest rack of a cold oven. Set the oven temperature to 275ºF and let the pizza warm for 25-35 minutes. 


Reheat Pizza in Microwave

Time: 45 second-1 minute

Rating: 2/10


Microwaving pizza is the fastest and most convenient choice in reheating–but at what cost? Everyone who has ever reheated their pizza in a microwave knows the disappointed taste of the soggy crust and overly greasy cheese. The way microwaves work makes reheating pizza difficult. Microwaves heat things up by turning the water content in the food to steam. That’s why it’s hard to make food crispy in the microwave, hence microwaving pizza might not be the best choice.

How to reheat pizza in a microwave in a way that decreases the likelihood of the pizza crust being soggy is suggested by Spoon University. They claim, “the simple addition of a glass of water will prevent pizza from getting soggy because the liquid in the glass will absorb some portion of the energy, it reduces the amount of energy going to the pizza and keeps the crust from getting chewy.


Reheat Pizza in Air Fryer

Time: 4-5 minutes

Temp: 320ºF

Rating: 4/10


Reheating a pizza in an air fryer might not be the first idea to pop into your mind considering it was invented in 2010. For those of you who don’t own an air fryer, it is essentially a downsized convection oven. They were made with the intention of crisping foods that would typically be fried in oil. The difference is, there’s minimal cleanup, and it’s faster. 


How to reheat pizza in an air fryer is fairly simple and the method that we share can be used across all models of air fryers. We took a page from the Dutch Oven Cookware site. All you need to do is slide your slice into the basket with no oil or anything else, cook for 4-5 minutes (or until it’s heated all the way through).  


The Best Pizza to Reheat From Empire Slice House – Plaza

What do you think the best way to reheat a pizza is? We think that reheating a pizza in the oven is the best route to go, depending on how long to reheat a slice of pizza in the oven. But let us know in the comments below what YOU think! If you still aren’t sure then stop by Empire Slice House – Plaza because we are a full service restaurant and bar that specializes in different variations of a NYC style pizza; so grab a pizza, reheat it tomorrow using our suggestions above, and let us know what the verdict is. Visit our website to view our full menus, to order pizza online, see our different locations, see our daily slices, apply for a job, or just to keep up with us on Instagram. Stop by Empire Slice House – Plaza and enjoy a piece of the most popular style of pizza in OKC! we look forward to seeing you at one of our local OKC pizza places!



Return to Empire OKC blog